Skip to main content

Miguel del Águila - DISAGREE!

Miguel del Águila's DISAGREE! was premiered by SOLI Chamber Ensemble in Austin, TX in 2017. True to its title, Disagree features competing themes which somehow coexist without ever coalescing into a unified whole. According to the program notes from the premier, "Disagree is a work about integrating disparity...[making] a statement about pluralism in music and in our society." 


To better understand the inherent conflict in this work, it is necessary to explore the composer's background. Miguel del Águila is a Uruguayan-American composer who studied in San Francisco and Vienna and has served as composer in residence at various institutions around the world. His music has a distinctly international sound without ever losing touch with his Latin American roots. In Disagree, we hear Latin inspired themes which are constantly interrupted by music which bears more European influence. The disagreement itself is almost cinematic in the way that themes transition; upon the initial listening, one might think that the recording had been haphazardly edited together by a sound engineer. The success of this effect can largely be attributed to the skill of the performers: SOLI Chamber Ensemble. 

Formed in 1994, SOLI Chamber Ensemble has spent the last 28 years committing their careers to the celebration of new music. Through various commissions and premiers, they have given voice to countless living composers and greatly contributed to the plethora of new chamber compositions in the 21st century. Their performance of Disagree highlights del Águila's virtuosic writing as well as the dramatic changes in mood, character, and style. 

There is no way to discuss a work for clarinet, violin, cello, and piano without acknowledging the historical significance of this instrumentation. The most famous work for this ensemble is Messiaen's Quartet for the End of Time, which he wrote and premiered as a prisoner of war during World War II. Since then, various 20th and 21st century composers have composed works for this ensemble, many of which feature similarly challenging themes. While Disagree does not tackle themes of war and faith, it does attempt to engage with the divisive political climate which has permeated every sphere of life in contemporary society. Thus, del Águila's work continues the legacy of chamber compositions which exist beyond the concert stage. 

~Marissa Kerbel

Comments

  1. UnknownFebruary 4, 2022 at 12:23 PM

    Your description is very apt for the sudden shifts. Wow. A complete halt for the soundings of every single instrument with a total texture change. I wonder how the ensemble manages creating the same effect in different halls! I've got to see it live to believe what I'm hearing is real (and accomplishable).

    JO

    ReplyDelete
  2. UnknownMarch 3, 2022 at 8:25 AM

    Hi there! What a fantastic piece! Thank you for sharing! I really enjoyed your recognition of the significance of the instrumentation in relation to Messiaen's Quartet for the End of Time. I originally didn't make this connection, so this was very helpful! I also enjoyed how you mentioned that this piece, though it doesn't cover the same themes as the Messiaen, it can also be seen as talking back to politics. It's commentary on current political discourse through expressing idealized world where we can disagree and coexist via a lot of different contrasting themes that don’t really ever merge into one another is so important. Thank you so much for sharing! -Abby Ryan

    ReplyDelete
  3. UnknownMarch 9, 2022 at 7:43 AM

    I really enjoyed hearing you presentation on this post. We should all be much more concerned with playing newer works. I think it's great that you not only sought out this piece to play for a recital, but are also getting to share it with your colleagues who will then be able to share it with future musicians they work with. The domino effect of programming and learning new music is profound.
    - Laura Ruple

    ReplyDelete
  4. UnknownApril 18, 2022 at 5:40 PM

    Hi Marissa! The music has one of the characteristics of postmodernism about pluralism. When I listen to the music by SOLI Chamber Ensemble, they require various techniques using their instruments, such as rapid scale and high pitch of the violin and piano. As a result, the music was complicated and ironic.
    -Haksung Lee

    ReplyDelete
  5. UnknownApril 18, 2022 at 7:45 PM

    Hi Marissa! I recently found his Miami Suite for flute and piano that I am looking forward to learning soon, but I hadn't gotten the chance yet to learn more about del Aguila. I appreciate that you introduced the class to him and I enjoyed learning more about him.
    Lianna

    ReplyDelete
  6. LydiaApril 22, 2022 at 7:55 PM

    Hi Marissa! This piece was pretty cool. I enjoyed reading about how the composer creates his sound and especially with this piece. The way you described how the talent of the musicians are responsible for the outcome and that it is something that would typical come from sound engineering. Thank you for sharing! -Lydia Young

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

VALERIE COLEMAN

Valerie Coleman is a Grammy-nominated composer and flutist.  She was a founding member of the Imani Winds wind quintet and is a current performer with the harp-viola-flute trio Umama Womama.  She is also currently the Clara Mannes Fellow for Music Leadership at the Mannes School of Music, serving on the flute and composition faculty.  Coleman has appeared with many orchestras, chamber groups, and on many records throughout her career.                                                                             She is also an accomplished composer and arranger.  In 2019 and 2020, the Philadelphia Orchestra commissioned her to arrange Umoja and write “Seven O’Clock Shout,” respectively.  Her piece Umoja has taken many forms, including wind quintet, concert band, and flute choir.  The word umoja is the Swahili word for “unity” and is the word associated with the first day of Kwanzaa.  The piece contains a call and response theme that represents unity in the music.  Seven O’Clock Shout was
10 comments
Read more

Menelaos Peistikos

  Menelaos Peistikos is a Greek composer and pianist currently based in Toronto, Canada. His music is inspired by an extreme variety of musical genres, ranging from baroque and renaissance music to contemporary classical and cinematic music, as well as from folk Greek to Japanese, Tibetan, and Indonesian Gamelan music. Peistikos is also heavily influenced by other artistic disciplines, especially by the oeuvres of Plato, Albert Camus, Friedrich Nietzsche, Alan Watts, and Edward Hopper. For Sun's Light: Molinari Quartet In February 2019, Menelaos won the  3rd Prize  and  1st Prize of Public  at the  7th Molinari String Quartet Composition Competition  in Montreal, Canada, for his string-quartet composition  For Sun’s light . In December 2018, he won the 2nd Prize at the  4th Opus Dissonus International Composition Competition  for solo piano in Brazil for his composition  On the Vision and The Riddle .  On the Vision and the Riddle He is a current student at the University of Toront
8 comments
Read more

_We Shall Not Be Moved_(2017) and Opera Philadelphia

We Shall Not Be Moved  was composed by Daniel Bernard Roumain with a libretto by Marc Bamuthi Joseph, and directed by Bill T. Jones. The opera brings in musical signifiers from several genres while pointedly critiquing issues such as police brutality, the rights of transgender individuals, and structural racism within the US public education system. While the opera has not been taken on by another company since its premiere in 2017, it is an overlooked example of the possibilities illuminated by the frameworks and orientations of Black Opera as defined by Naomi André , and, I would argue, contemporary US opera more broadly.  The opera grew out of an Opera Philadelphia collaboration with a non-profit called Arts Sanctuary called  "Hip H'Opera,"  initially launched in 2007. In the Hip H'Opera program, students "[learned] the history and aesthetics of hip-hop and opera . . . and then "[used] poetry, fiction, and non-fiction [to capture] their own urban stories.
1 comment
Read more